WED 465 The Human Resource Specialist
Question Description
Have to write an analytical summary paper based on the article : The role of the corporate HR function in global talent management.(attached) Description of what the instruction is looking for is on page 5 of the syllabus (attached) I also have to compare this article to the same topic discussed in textbook: Human Resource Managment: Gaining a Competitive Advantage 10th edition by Noe, Hollenbeck, Gerhart and Wright. The questions that need to be answered are on page 6 of the syllabus (attached). I have also attached a sample of what the paper should look like and the rubric it will be graded against.
| Poor (0-3) | Good (4-7) | Best (8-10) | |
| I. The most important point of the article. Citing evidence for support. | Main point is not stated. No evidence for support provided.
|
Main point of the article is identified but is not clearly stated. Supporting evidence is not clearly stated. | Main point is clearly stated and supporting evidence is clearly stated. |
| II. Article and the text. | No effort is made to relate the article’s content to the content in course readings. |
Some effort is made to connect the article’s content to our text or other readings. | Effort relating the article’s concepts to our course readings is evident and clearly stated.
|
| III. What are the assumptions &/or biases? | No statement about assumptions or biases is made. |
Assumptions and biases are addressed but not clearly stated. |
Assumptions and biases are addressed and clearly stated |
| IV. How do the author’s points resonate with your experience? | No discussion relating the learner’s experience to the article’s concepts or point of view. |
There is discussion relating the learner’s experience to the article’s concepts and/or point of view but these are not clearly stated. | Learner discusses her/his experience in regard to the author’s concepts or point of view. |
| V. What is new, or why is nothing new? What are your questions? |
No discussion of ideas or thinking that is new to the learner; no effort to project why these topics are familiar. No questions are posed by the learner. |
Learner makes moderate effort to discuss new ideas or to explore why these ideas are familiar. Questions are posed about the article’s content. | Learner has a substantive discussion about new ideas or explores in some depth why these ideas are not new to him or her. Questions are posed about the article’s content. |
| Total |